While the film is often criticized for its CGI and departures from historical or mythological accuracy, some reviewers noted it as a "watchable" B-movie that delivers decent action and spectacle for fans of the sword-and-sand genre. In Hindi-speaking regions, it remains a popular choice for home viewing alongside other titles in The Mummy and Scorpion King universe.

Critics were harsh upon release, citing lower production values compared to the Universal theatrical releases. However, time has been kind to the film. Viewed today, it is a competent fantasy adventure. It expands the lore of the Scorpion King, introducing elements like the Minotaur and the duplicitous goddess Astarte. It answers the question of how Mathayus became the man who would one day dare to challenge an empire.